Three weeks have passed since 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie failed to show up for Sunday church services in Tucson, Arizona. Since then, a nation has been watching — and waiting — as one of the most intensive missing persons investigations in recent memory has yielded few public breakthroughs and growing theories about who is behind her disappearance.
Now, a private investigator with more than three decades of experience is stepping forward with one of the boldest assessments yet: Bill Garcia believes a cartel took Nancy Guthrie — but says she never crossed into Mexico.
A Case That Has Gripped the Nation
Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance on or around February 1, 2026 became national news almost immediately, in no small part because of who her daughter is. Savannah Guthrie, the well-known co-anchor of NBC’s Today show, has publicly pleaded for her mother’s safe return, even recording a video in which she told potential informants, “It’s never too late to do the right thing.”
Her mother vanished from her home in the Catalina Foothills neighborhood of Tucson — a quiet, upscale area roughly 60 miles north of the U.S.-Mexico border. Surveillance footage captured at least two individuals at her front door the night of the disappearance. One wore a ski mask. Evidence collected at the scene points to a violent confrontation between Nancy and whoever took her.
The FBI has fielded more than 20,000 tips. Hundreds of investigators from multiple agencies remain actively assigned to the case. The only item positively linked to the crime so far is an Ozark Trail backpack. All family members, including siblings and their spouses, have been officially cleared.
The PI’s Bold Theory
Bill Garcia, now based near Sacramento, has spent his career working missing persons and criminal cases throughout California and the Southwest. He says Tucson’s geography makes it a natural hub for drug and human trafficking operations — one he has navigated professionally for years.
“That particular area of Arizona is a high drug and money transporting area,” Garcia told Border Report. He believes whoever took Nancy Guthrie did so for financial gain, operating with the kind of calculated structure associated with organized criminal networks. The person captured in the surveillance footage outside her front door, Garcia says, is the critical clue.
But Garcia breaks sharply with theories that Nancy was smuggled across the border. The law enforcement presence and surveillance infrastructure between Tucson and Mexico is simply too dense, he argues. Instead, he suspects she is being held somewhere in a roughly 100-to-130-mile corridor north of Tucson — between the city and the outskirts of Phoenix and Mesa.
“They would have to choose a location that’s safe and where they’re less likely to be caught in the act,” he explained. “To me, that would be a more logical place to look for Nancy.”
Garcia was careful to note he is not inserting himself into the official investigation, but said he would willingly offer his expertise if asked.
Experts Are Divided
Not everyone agrees with the cartel angle. A former FBI agent publicly outlined seven reasons why the kidnapping’s methods don’t align with typical cartel operations. Cartels, experts note, traditionally do not target private U.S. homes. Their kidnapping operations tend to focus on migrants in transit — on buses, freight trains, or moving through stash houses along the border.
The Pima County Sheriff’s Office has confirmed there is no current evidence Nancy was taken to Mexico, and Mexican authorities in the bordering state of Sonora stated they had not yet received a formal request for assistance from U.S. law enforcement.
However, a former U.S. Marshal offered a middle-ground perspective: while the methods may not match those of a major transnational cartel, Tucson-area street gangs with ties to the Sinaloa cartel — which the former marshal described as “ground zero” for fentanyl trafficking into the U.S. — cannot be ruled out.
The Investigation Continues
On the forensic front, investigators are still analyzing biological evidence, including DNA, recovered from Nancy Guthrie’s home. Authorities were careful to clarify that this is not new evidence — it is the same material collected early in the investigation, now undergoing further testing.
Meanwhile, anonymous emails demanding payment for information on the abductors were sent to TMZ, which ultimately offered to help direct the writer to law enforcement so they could claim the reward. The Guthrie family has said publicly that they are willing to pay for Nancy’s safe return.
The Pima County Sheriff’s Department released a statement saying the investigation remains fully active: “As long as leads continue to come in, investigators will continue to follow up on them.”
For the thousands of people following this case — and the family waiting at home — that is both a comfort and a reminder that time remains of the essence.
If you have any information about Nancy Guthrie’s whereabouts, contact the FBI tip line or local Pima County law enforcement immediately.