In the quiet town of Cordele, Georgia, Janie Lou Gibbs charmed everyone as a pious wife, Sunday school teacher, and daycare operator. Born on Christmas Day 1932, she seemed the picture of family devotion with husband Charles and their three boys—until tragedy struck repeatedly between 1966 and 1967. What looked like a cursed household hiding hereditary illness was actually cold-blooded murder for insurance money.
​
A Trail of Suspicious Deaths
It began January 21, 1966, when 39-year-old Charles Gibbs died after eating Janie’s home-cooked meal laced with arsenic, misdiagnosed as liver disease. She collected insurance, donated part to her supportive church, and faced no questions. Eight months later, 13-year-old Marvin collapsed with cramps and died on August 29, blamed on inherited hepatitis—another payout, another church gift.
​
Then 16-year-old Melvin perished suddenly on January 23, 1967, from a supposed rare muscle disorder, netting Janie $31,000 total while she tithed generously to deflect suspicion. Her eldest, 19-year-old Roger—who’d just made her a grandma—watched his one-month-old son Ronnie die in October 1967. Roger followed weeks later, prompting his wife to demand an autopsy that uncovered lethal arsenic levels.

Exhumations, Arrest, and Justice
Doctors exhumed the others; all five bodies showed arsenic poisoning from rat poison Janie methodically fed them. Arrested Christmas Eve 1967, she confessed but claimed no motive beyond warped beliefs. Deemed insane in 1968, she cooked in a mental hospital until fit for trial in 1976, earning five life sentences. Paroled in 1999 due to Parkinson’s, she died February 7, 2010, in a nursing home.
​
The case, verified across sources like Wikipedia and crime archives, highlights how faith and generosity masked greed—no discrepancies found in core facts.